BoxScore Geeks' 2014 New York Knicks Preview

The Numbers

  •  Average Seed
  • 📉 Pessimist
    29.2 wins
  •  Realist
    37.5 wins
  • 📈 Optimist
    45.8 wins
 First Seed
⋆ Division
 Top 4
👍 Over (40.5)
ğŸ‘Ž Under (40.5)
ğŸŽ€ Playoffs

The Brief

For once, we feel that the New York Knicks are going to be a tough nut to project. On paper it seems fairly straightforward. New York is a borderline 40-win team. They cannot defend a lick (a Calderon, JR, Melo, Stat and Bargs line is enough to make Tom Thibodeau grimace all the way from Chicago) , but they have some pretty efficient scorers. The real question, though, is whether Phil Jackson is done with this roster. Phil being Phil likely means he's not going to want to begin Melo's outrageous contract with a losing season. A move or moves using those expiring contracts on the roster seem not just likely but inevitable. 

The Story

We were pretty clear about the Knicks last year. Jason Kidd was half-man/half-wizard in leading the Knicks to play beautiful basketball on route to a 52-win season in 2012-13. When Kidd retired from playing and was replaced by the comedic stylings of Raymond Felton, the Vegas over/under of 51.5 for 2013-14 not only felt but actually was ridiculously high. When the Knicks took Masai Ujiri's call and traded a capable reserve (Steve Novak) for the worst player in the NBA (Andrea Bargnani), it was all I could do to keep myself from putting the whole bankroll on the under (letting your whole bankroll ride on one bet, no matter how good that bet is, is a terrible idea).

Carmelo Anthony made things pretty interesting by having a career year. Bargnani got injured to keep the team's playoff hopes alive longer than they should have been, but, in the end, the 2013-14 season was exactly the trainwreck we thought it would be.

Last Year

  •  Actual Wins: 37
  •  Expected Wins: 43.3
  • ⚅ Lucky Wins: 1.2
Player Minutes Age WP48 Wins
Carmelo Anthony 2,982 30 0.161 10.0
J.R. Smith 2,421 28 0.079 4.0
Raymond Felton  2,017 30 0.072 3.0
Iman Shumpert 1,962 24 0.109 4.5
Tim Hardaway Jr. 1,875 22 0.048 1.9
Tyson Chandler  1,662 31 0.222 7.7
Amare Stoudemire 1,466 31 0.096 2.9
Pablo Prigioni 1,283 37 0.216 5.8
Andrea Bargnani 1,257 28 -0.049 -1.3
Kenyon Martin 633 36 0.081 1.1
Beno Udrih  588 32 0.075 0.9
Jeremy Tyler  398 23 0.010 0.1
Metta World Peace 388 34 0.035 0.3
Toure' Murry  373 24 -0.002 0
Cole Aldrich 330 25 0.319 2.2
Shannon Brown  148 28 0.035 0.1
Earl Clark  70 26 0.090 0.1
Chris Smith 2 26 0.019 0

 Indicates that the player is no longer with the team.

  • 43.3 total Wins Produced
  •  7 players leaving
    (5256.0 minutes, 11.9 wins)

J.R. Smith actually had a fairly decent second half; early on, it looked like he was going to challenge Rashad McCant's spot for the worst shooting guard season of all time. The sixth man of the year award is always a joke (the analysis voters do here begins and ends at "points per game"), but he was a particularly undeserving candidate in 2013, since he wasn't even the best reserve on the Knicks (those were Novak and Prigioni).

So replacing Kidd with Felton was also doomed to go badly. Adding Andrea Bargnani to the Knicks was even worse, but it did keep the internet basketball MEME machine afloat:

nodunkno can play D

It's not just the eye test that makes Bargs look bad. It's actually pretty difficult to find any statistical category in which Bargs is not below average for a big man. One is blocks (he's about average), and the other is personal fouls (but a quick look at how he plays defense might lead you to question whether this is a good thing).

Let's put this in context. Bargs isn't just one of the worst players in the NBA; he is, by some measures, the worst of all time. Usually, terrible players don't get to compete for "worst of all time" honors because it is hard to pile up lots of minutes while playing horrific basketball. In fact, it's hard to keep a roster spot. Ask Adam Morrison, Rashad McCants, or Michael Beasley. Bargnani, though, has somehow managed the trick of playing over 14,000 NBA minutes while producing a spectacular negative 18.9 wins. The list of players with more than 14000 minutes and less than zero wins produced is only 11 players long. Everybody on it but Andrea Bargnani and Al Harrington stem from older eras, when "advanced" analysis meant maybe keeping track of blocks or turnovers. Bargs -18.9 is the lowest WP total on that list, and he is far and away the worst per-minute player (second place isn't even close). Bargs has somehow managed to "produce more losses" than James Edwards' -17.5, despite having played about 10,000 fewer minutes than Edwards. And he's still got at least one more year to go!

This Year

  •  Projected Wins: 37.5
  •  Conference Rank: 8
  • % Playoffs: 61.9
Player Position Minutes Age WP48 Wins
Carmelo Anthony 3.0 2,384.3 31 0.164 8.1
Jose Calderon  1.0 2,251.3 33 0.146 6.9
J.R. Smith 2.0 2,131.3 30 0.058 2.6
Samuel Dalembert  5.0 2,067.1 34 0.139 6.0
Andrea Bargnani 4.0 1,955.7 29 0.028 1.1
Amare Stoudemire 4.0 1,138.6 32 0.053 1.3
Jason Smith  5.0 1,105.5 29 0.004 0.1
Pablo Prigioni 1.0 1,104.3 38 0.143 3.3
Iman Shumpert 2.0 1,089.8 25 0.072 1.6
Cole Aldrich 5.0 681.5 26 0.209 3.0
Travis Outlaw  3.5 644.8 30 0.014 0.2
Cleanthony Early  3.0 515.1 0 0.016 0.2
Shane Larkin  1.0 481.4 22 0.021 0.2
Quincy Acy  4.0 467.0 24 0.134 1.3
Orlando Sanchez  4.0 449.7 0 0.004 0

 Indicates that the player is new to the team.

  • 📅 40.5 WP last year
    by these players
  • 🔀 2.7 WP (roster changes)
  • ⏲ -.6 WP (age/experience)

This year looks like more of the same...on paper. What the team loses in defense and rebounding from Chandler, it gains in shooting efficiency, passing, and ball control from replacing Felton with Calderon. And although Dalembert is way past his prime, he's still a productive center, certainly a step up from Bargnani and Stoudemire.

But that's "on paper". Where things get interesting is if certain trade scenarios develop.

  • What happens in December, after the Pacers realize how much of a train wreck their team is, and decide that David West or George Hill are no longer worth keeping?
  • Kobe will be horribly overpaid no matter what, but if he regains his 2013 form, he's still a good player. What happens if he decides he can't stand losing that much and waives his no-trade clause? New York seems like the one place that a) he would go (because of Phil and Derek) and b) would actually want him and his huge contract (in exchange for Stoudemire's huge contract. LA would do this because Amare's contract expires, saving LA tons of money next year).
  • What if Flip the GM wins a staring contest with Flip the Coach and decides blowing it up is better than trying to win 35 games? Would Minnesota trade Kevin Martin and Nikola Pekovic for Stoudemire's expiring and the Knicks' 2017 1st round pick?
  • Can Phil find anybody willing to take Bargnani's expiring deal for anything of value?

The scenarios get complicated but basically if anyone decides to blow things up and can take back Stoudemire's or Bargnani's contract (or, gasp, both), the Knicks could have a real opportunity to improve by 4-5 wins. This could mean a playoff seed. 

The Wrap

Just like last year, the Knicks are going to have huge problems defending anybody. Carmelo Anthony will probably be their best defender, and that should scare the hell out of most Knicks fans. But it's really hard to bet against Phil Jackson, even when he's not on the sidelines. It wouldn't surprise me at all if New York is active in the trade market, trying to turn some of its huge expiring contracts into warm bodies that produce some wins.

There are, after all, more than a few reasons to think Phil knows what he's doing.